Theft or inspiration: the epic surf film that Beyoncé ripped off for Lemonade
- Text by Gabriela Helfet
- Photography by View From A Blue Moon // Laurene Boglio
If Beyoncé Knowles is Planet Earth’s reigning Queen of Soundwaves, John John Florence is the Prince of Tides.
Last year, Florence and Director Blake Vincent Kueny released an epic, grandiose as fuck, surf flick. Some of the world marvelled at its majesty. This is the July 2015 teaser for View From A Blue Moon:
In 2016, Beyoncé released an epic, grandiose as fuck, audio visual opus. Most of the world marvelled at its majesty. This is the April 2016 teaser for Lemonade.
Now, here they are combined into one. This is JohnceKnowles.
Yeah the shots are different, but the pacing, the way the music is synced with the shots, hell the entire editing sequence really, is pretty much exactly the same.
Beyoncé has already been accused of “borrowing” other artists’ ideas for Lemonade’s first music video: Formation.
But here’s the rub. Where her audio is concerned, Knowles is, seemingly, straight diligent. On Don’t Hurt Yourself she’s gone so far as to credit Robert Plant, presumably because she sampled a teensy snippet of a Led Zeppelin track.
So what’s the deal? Are the films Bey ‘samples from’ somehow less deserving of a nod than the music? Is this just a case of innocent inspiration, that the Internet is kicking up unnecessary fuss about? After all, according to Picasso, “Good artists copy, great artists steal.”
Or maybe, just maybe (!!!) the real message behind Lemonade is that Beyoncé is a secret surfer girl ready to shoot the curl at Mavericks… Sure hope it’s that last one. (Surfbort).
Enjoyed this article? Like Huck on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.
You might like
In Birmingham’s punk underground, hardcore is queer
Punk Pride — In recent years, a defiantly political queercore scene has begun to emerge in the West Midlands, providing alternative spaces for the area’s LGBTQ+ youth. Stephanie Phillips speaks to those leading the charge.
Written by: Stephanie Phillips
We took techno legend Chris Liberator to a virtual rave, here’s what went down
Stay acid forever — With VR experience In Pursuit of Repetitive Beats currently running at London's Barbican Centre, Simon Doherty brought the acid punk figurehead along to see what he thought, and reflect on the health of the rave scene today.
Written by: Simon Doherty
Bob Vylan top UK Hip Hop and R&B album chart one week after Glastonbury
The people said ‘Nah’ — Despite heavy criticism from politicians and media for leading chants of “death to the IDF”, as well as being dropped by their agent, the punk duo’s 2024 LP 'Humble As The Sun' has seen its purchases and streams spike.
Written by: Molly Baker
Kneecap now have 1.5 million monthly Spotify listeners
Not the story — The number has tripled from 500,000 in January, and comes after months of criticism from media and politicians as the Irish rap trio have expressed support for Palestine.
Written by: Molly Baker
In photos: The people of Glastonbury’s queer heart The NYC Downlow
Elation and family — Once a year, a meatpacking warehouse nightclub springs up in Glastonbury’s South East corner and becomes a site of pilgrimage for the festival’s LGBTQ+ scene. We met the people who make The NYC Downlow so special.
Written by: Isaac Muk
How pop music introduced queer culture to the mainstream
The Secret Public — Between the ’50s to the ’70s, pop music was populated with scene pushers from the margins. A new book by Jon Savage explores the powerful influence of LGBTQ+ folk.
Written by: Miss Rosen
