The Palestinian director who earned a fatwa for her first film
- Text by Dominique Sisley
When Maysaloun Hamoud first heard about her fatwa, she was shaken. The religious ruling – widely seen as a formalised “death sentence” – seemed like an extreme reaction for a woman who’d just released a Palestinian comedy. “It was pathetic,” the director says, remembering the moment she heard the news. “I wasn’t afraid, but I felt a kind of sorrow.”
The film at the centre of the furore was In Between – Hamoud’s first ever feature. Set in Tel Aviv, it follows the story of three Israeli-Palestinian women as they attempt to share an apartment. It’s a raw and real portrayal of everyday womanhood, with each character struggling to navigate between family constraints, Islamic tradition, and cosmopolitan liberalism.
While it’s true that women’s stories are rarely – if ever – told in Palestinian cinema, that’s not where the controversy stops. In Between is a true taboo-breaker. The women in the film (all of whom are Muslim) have casual sex, do drugs, and go out clubbing. You’re introduced to Salma, a restaurant worker trying to become a DJ; Laila, a hard-partying lawyer looking for love; and Dounia, a trainee doctor trying to hide a lesbian relationship.
Hamoud wasn’t unaware of the controversy when she began writing the project, which is partly why it took her so long to bring it to the big screen. “I started to write the script five years ago, before the Arab spring,” she explains. “Eventually, the voice that I wanted to bring to Palestinian cinema became the same voice that the young people of the Arab world were shouting in the squares.”
“It was about changing the system from the bottom, making justice for society, and hearing the voices of women. Everyone wanted to talk about the taboos – sex, independence, the patriarchy, who rules in the regimes. It empowered me to continue with the movie-making process.”
Hamoud, who is of Palestinian descent herself, grew up in Dir Hanna – a small village in the North of Israel. Passionate about political and social change in the region, she obtained a Masters in Middle-Eastern history and began working for the Tel Aviv based NGO, SADAKA. However, after growing frustrated with the political world’s glacial rate of progress, she turned to filmmaking. “Through art, I can affect more people,” she adds. “I can create something more powerful through cinema.”
Now she lives in Jaffa, a district in the south of Tel Aviv, which is also where In Between is set. “Jaffa is just a big white Jewish city,” the director says, jokingly. “It seems to have a reputation as a liberal and open-minded place, but it’s just like the whole state of Israel, which is the opposite of liberal and accepting. It makes Palestinians feel like they are second-class citizens.”
Hamoud admits that, as well as the fatwa, she’s also received death threats, with many Palestinians furious about the film’s free-spirited protagonists. The movie has even sent shockwaves through Israel, she claims, with many Jewish citizens surprised by the character’s accessibility and open-mindedness. “You can feel the shock that Israelis got from the movie,” she adds. “It’s breaking all the stereotypes that they have about us.”
Despite the storm of controversy surrounding the film, however, Hamoud shows no signs of stopping. The director is currently working on a TV series (a dark, criminal comedy in the vein of Ozark and Breaking Bad), and she also intends to make two more sequels to In Between.
“We are in very crucial time,” she says, when asked about her motivation. “Israel has a very fascistic and racist government, and Palestinian’s have suffered a lot.”
“We don’t have the privilege to sit and do nothing because we have a lot of very scary and serious things going on around us.”
Latest on Huck
My sister disappeared when we were children. Years later, I retraced her footsteps
After a car crash that saw Magnum photographer Lindokuhle Sobekwa hospitalised, his sister ran away from their home in South Africa. His new photobook, I Carry Her Photo With Me, documents his journey in search of her.
Written by: Lindokuhle Sobekwa
Inside New York City’s hedonistic 2000s skateboarding scene
New photobook, ‘Epicly Later’d’ is a lucid survey of the early naughties New York skate scene and its party culture.
Written by: Isaac Muk
Did we create a generation of prudes?
Has the crushing of ‘teen’ entertainment and our failure to represent the full breadth of adolescent experience produced generation Zzz? Emma Garland investigates.
Written by: Emma Garland
How to shoot the world’s most gruelling race
Photographer R. Perry Flowers documented the 2023 edition of the Winter Death Race and talked through the experience in Huck 81.
Written by: Josh Jones
An epic portrait of 20th Century America
‘Al Satterwhite: A Retrospective’ brings together scenes from this storied chapter of American life, when long form reportage was the hallmark of legacy media.
Written by: Miss Rosen
Bobby Gillespie: “This country is poisoned by class”
Primal Scream’s legendary lead singer writes about the band’s latest album ‘Come Ahead’ and the themes of class, conflict and compassion that run throughout it.
Written by: Bobby Gillespie