What it means to be 15 and female, anywhere...
- Text by Ilana PanIch-lInsman
- Photography by Ilana PanIch-lInsman
Adolescence, with all its chemical shifts, is universal. Yet its manifestations differ according to context.
I photographed 15-year-old girls from Brooklyn, New York, because I was curious about this moment when the push and pull of childhood and adulthood can be equally strong.
It’s when a girl begins to define herself as a woman. I became curious about cultural differences in this age group, so I followed the idea from Brooklyn to Palestinian refugee camps in Lebanon and Jordan.
While it may seem like an obvious comparison, I’ve never seen the two sets of photographs juxtaposed as they are before you here.
These images have ceased functioning as interplay between my eye, my subjects and myself; they’ve become a dialogue revealing religious, political, social and cultural differences and similarities between two small corners of female teenage culture.
Each pairing of images has been matched with a song, which you can listen to as a mix on Spotify.
The Slits – Typical Girls
Top: Katie (15) and friends sit in Libby’s bedroom in Park Slope, Brooklyn, an upper-middle-class section of New York City.
Bottom: Manam (20), Manar (23), Fidaa (18), and Khitam (13), four sisters from Wadi Dawasit, Saudi Arabia, sit in their room in Gaza Camp, Jerash, Jordan – home to more than 20,000 Gazan refugees.
Bikini Kill – Rebel Girls
Top: Hannah (15) smokes a cigarette outside a music venue in Manhattan,
New York City.
Bottom: Riham Al-Quesi (16) at her home in Beddowi camp, Tripoli, Lebanon.
Paul Simon – Me and Julio Down by the Schoolyard
Top:Hannah (15) and Libby (15) embrace in front of their former elementary school in Park Slope, Brooklyn.
Bottom: A young girl adjusts her hijab outside an elementary school run by the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA).
Nirvana – Bloom
Top: Libby performs a cartwheel in Prospect Park, Brooklyn, where she and her friends often hang out.
Bottom: A teenager waves over a wall at Jerash Camp.
The Smiths – Please, Please, Please, Let Me Get What I Want
Top: Libby dresses for school. She attends a rigorous high school in Park Slope and plans to go to college.
Bottom: Shahanez (13) was born in Gaza Camp. Her family came from Ramla in Palestine.
Shahanaz loves school and hopes to become a doctor, but will not be able to do so unless her legal status as a refugee changes, thereby affording her the same rights as local citizens.
Beastie Boys – Fight For Your Right (To Party)
Top: Hannah smoking at a party with her boyfriend.
Bottom: A girl laughs with friends. Young Muslim women in the camps rarely spend time with boys from outside their own families.
Deftones – Be Quiet and Drive (Far Away)
Top:Katie (15) rides the subway home from school every day, alone or with friends.
Bottom: Mona Mhmad Al Masri (15) at her home in Burj El-Barajneh camp in the outskirts of Beirut, Lebanon.
Against Me! – Pretty Girls (The Mover)
Top: Hannah checks herself in the mirror at a party.
Bottom: Saher Taweh (21), Ruba (20) and Kamar Wakad (18) chat with Wafaa Zeid (17) while they take turns applying makeup to one another during a beauty class held by UNRWA in Beddowi Camp, Tripoli, Lebanon.
Weezer – Smart Girls
Top: Libby studies for her classes while her father prepares dinner in Brooklyn.
Bottom: Girls take notes in class at an UNRWA school in Beddowi Camp, Tripoli, Lebanon.
Find out more about Ilana Panich-Linsman’s Fifteen project or listen to the above mix on Spotify.
This article originally appeared in Huck 33 – The Identity Issue. Subscribe today to make sure you never miss another issue.
Enjoyed this article? Like Huck on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.
Latest on Huck
Nxdia: “Poems became an escape for me”
What Made Me — In this series, we ask artists and rebels about the forces and experiences that shaped who they are. Today, it’s Egyptian-British alt-pop shapeshifter Nxdia.
Written by: Nxdia
Kathy Shorr’s splashy portraits inside limousines
The Ride of a Lifetime — Wanting to marry a love of cars and photography, Kathy Shorr worked as a limousine driver in the ’80s to use as a studio on wheels. Her new photobook explores her archive.
Written by: Miss Rosen
Lewd tales of live sex shows in ’80s Times Square
Peep Man — Before its LED-beaming modern refresh, the Manhattan plaza was a hotbed for seedy transgression. A new memoir revisits its red light district heyday.
Written by: Miss Rosen
In a world of noise, IC3PEAK are finding radicality in the quiet
Coming Home — Having once been held up as a symbol of Russian youth activism and rebellion, the experimental duo are now living in exile. Their latest album explores their new reality.
Written by: Isaac Muk
Are we steamrolling towards the apocalypse?
One second closer to midnight — While the rolling news cycle, intensifying climate crisis and rapidly advancing technology can make it feel as if the end days are upon us, newsletter columnist Emma Garland remembers that things have always been terrible, and that is a natural part of human life.
Written by: Emma Garland
In a city of rapid gentrification, one south London estate stands firm
A Portrait of Central Hill — Social housing is under threat across the British capital. But residents of the Central Hill estate in Crystal Palace are determined to save their homes, and their community.
Written by: Alex King